Promotion Process ‘Not Fit For Purpose’

The Chair of South Yorkshire Police Federation said he agreed with the independent Police Leadership Commission that policing was not short of talent or commitment, but that leadership development across the service is often inconsistent, fragmented and under-resourced.

The Commission’s report, ‘Professionalism and Performance: Police Leadership for the Future’, was discussed at last month’s PFEW conference, and the key message was that leadership matters at every rank.

Panellists highlighted the vital role played by frontline supervisors, Sergeants and Inspectors in shaping culture, morale, wellbeing and performance, arguing that leadership development should begin early and continue throughout an officer’s career.

South Yorkshire Police Federation Chair Steve Kent said: “There are changes going on within our force in terms of Sergeants and Inspectors’ promotion process, but in general terms, the promotion process within policing is not fit for purpose. It promotes people on the basis of the ability to pass a process rather than to do the role.

“Obviously we have some cracking Sergeants and Inspectors who get promoted, I’m not saying this is a general thing, but there are also people who might be going for promotion for the wrong reasons, there might be people who are not suitable for it, and the force isn’t dealing with that properly and isn’t identifying the correct talent.

“So we need to urgently look at our promotion processes. Because to be blunt, the vast majority of incidents that go in front of professional standards should have been dealt with by first or second line managers. So then you’re tying up professional standards and you’re putting that officer through months and months of worry, for something which is at a low level and should have been dealt with confidently by the first or second line supervisor. That is happening every single week in this force.

“It’s absolutely vital that we find the right leaders who are going to make good positive decisions in terms of what their officers are doing, and help define the culture within the organisation.

“Currently, if people can pass a process, we’re just allowing them through, and that is not right. If you promote someone who isn’t ready, it causes problems and that drips down to the whole team.”

But, Steve added: “In this force, we have teams of officers who are led very, very well. The performance, conduct and culture within those teams is impeccable. So this isn’t a problem across the force, it’s just down to bad managers on a case-by-case basis.”